Choosing between metal roofing and asphalt shingles is one of the most consequential decisions for any homeowner. Price, longevity, maintenance, energy efficiency, and aesthetics all play a part—yet every property’s needs differ. In this Aureate Face-Off, we’ll unpack the critical factors you need to weigh, highlight how local Roofers near me approach each material, and equip you with a decision framework that aligns with your budget, climate, and design goals.
In fact, when homeowners search for Roofers near me, many choose Elite Contracting for their proven expertise in both metal and asphalt installations. Let’s dive in.
Key Factors Roofers near me Consider When Choosing Roofing Materials
Local roofing professionals evaluate every project through a consistent lens:
- Upfront vs. Lifetime Cost
Asphalt shingles are favored for low initial outlay, while metal roofing demands more capital but can pay for itself through durability and energy savings. - Climate & Durability Needs
Areas prone to hail, heavy snow, or wildfires often benefit from metal’s superior resistance, whereas regions with milder weather may find asphalt adequate. - Maintenance Tolerance
Asphalt systems require annual inspections and periodic shingle replacements; metal panels largely shrug off routine upkeep beyond a quick biannual check. - Energy Efficiency Goals
Reflective metal panels can slash cooling loads, making them attractive in sun-belt climates. Asphalt options often need specialized reflective coatings to approach similar savings. - Aesthetic & Architectural Fit
The choice between traditional shingle profiles and sleek metal lines can make or break a home’s curb appeal, especially in highly visible neighborhoods. - Environmental Impact
Eco-minded homeowners and contractors often lean metal for its recyclability and potential to roof over existing shingles, reducing landfill waste.
With these factors in mind, let’s explore each dimension in depth.
Cost Comparison: Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roofing
- Asphalt Shingles
- Material & Installation: $4–$8 per sq ft (3-tab to luxury architectural), plus standard labor rates.
- Upfront Appeal: Attractive to budget-conscious homeowners and widely available.
- Long-Term Replacement: Average lifespan of 20–30 years may require two or three re-roofs over a 60-year span.
- Metal Roofing
- Material & Installation: $4.50–$16 per sq ft for steel standing seam; premium metals (copper, zinc) up to $50 per sq ft.
- Specialized Labor: Requires skilled installers—costs reflect seaming, fastening, and underlayment expertise.
- Lifecycle Value: Lasts 40–80+ years, often never needing a full replacement.
For a deeper cost breakdown, see our 2025 Roof Replacement Cost Guide, which details regional pricing and installation scenarios.
Durability & Lifespan
- Asphalt Shingles
- Typical Lifespan: 20 years for basic 3-tab; 25–30 years for architectural or luxury lines.
- Vulnerabilities: Prone to hail impact, wind uplift, thermal cycling damage, granule loss, and algae growth in humid climates.
- Metal Roofing
- Typical Lifespan: 40–70 years for painted steel; copper, stainless steel, and zinc can exceed 80 years.
- Weather Resistance: Class 4 UL 2218 hail rating, Class A fire rating, wind warranties up to 120 mph, and excellent snow-slide performance.
In hail- or wind-prone Upstate New York environments, metal often provides peace of mind that asphalt can’t match.
Maintenance Needs
- Asphalt Shingles
- Annual Inspections: Check for cracked, warped, or missing shingles; clear debris (leaves, branches) to prevent water backup.
- Repairs: Spot-replace damaged shingles and reseal flashing or vents as needed—typically every 5–10 years.
- Metal Roofing
- Low Upkeep: Yearly or every-other-year visual checks for loose panels, fastener corrosion, or sealant wear.
- Panel Integrity: Metal doesn’t warp, crack, or lose granules, translating to fewer worry cycles.
Energy Efficiency & Sustainability
- Asphalt Shingles
- Heat Absorption: Dark shingles can raise attic temperatures, bumping up cooling costs.
- Reflective Options: Special coatings can reflect 20–30% of solar heat but add marginal premium to material cost.
- Metal Roofing
- Reflectivity: Mirrors up to 40% of solar radiant heat, lowering A/C loads by 10–25%.
- Recyclable Content: Many panels contain 25–95% recycled steel/aluminum and are 100% recyclable at end of life.
- Roof-Over Capability: Metal panels can often be installed directly over existing asphalt, reducing tear-off waste.
At a time when sustainability matters, metal frequently emerges as the eco-friendliest choice without sacrificing performance.
Aesthetic Appeal & Curb Impact
- Asphalt Shingles
- Variety: Available in a spectrum of colors and profiles (3-tab, architectural, luxury) with options that mimic wood shakes or slate.
- Traditional Look: Complements colonial, bungalow, and ranch-style homes with a familiar silhouette.
- Metal Roofing
- Profiles & Finishes: Standing seam, stone-coated shake or tile profiles in bold and muted hues; offers three-dimensional depth.
- Architectural Accent: Sharp lines and color uniformity enhance modern, farmhouse, and transitional designs.
Both materials can elevate curb appeal when specified and installed thoughtfully.
Environmental Considerations
- Asphalt Shingles
- Landfill Impact: Most old shingles end up in landfills—over 10 million tons annually in the U.S.¹
- Recycling Programs: Limited to select regions where shingles are repurposed for paving or road base.
- Metal Roofing
- Recyclability: Almost entirely recyclable at the end of service life; new panels often contain recycled content.
- Waste Reduction: Roof-over installs avoid disposal of old materials, slashing environmental footprint.
Homeowners prioritizing green building standards almost always favor metal in comparative analyses.
Noise & Insulation
- Asphalt Shingles
- Sound Dampening: The granular surface and layered mat structure muffle rain and hail noise effectively.
- Metal Roofing
- Rain Noise: Can be noticeable without proper underlayment and insulation; pairing with sound-absorbing underlays or attic insulation addresses most concerns.
- Thermal Performance: Metal can transmit heat or cold but pairs well with reflective coatings and rigid insulation boards.
When properly detailed, metal roofs can achieve noise levels comparable to shingles.
Installation & Contractor Expertise
Installation quality is non-negotiable for both systems. Key considerations include:
- Weather Windows: Asphalt requires moderate temperatures for optimal sealing of shingles and adhesives. Metal panels can often be installed year-round, even in near-freezing conditions.
- Skill Set: Metal installation demands precise panel alignment, specialized fasteners, and careful underlayment to prevent leaks at seams.
- Local Expertise: When you search for Roofers near me, look for teams with extensive metal-panel portfolios and certified training.
- Cost Analysis: Refer to our 2025 Roof Replacement Cost Guide for regional labor and material breakdowns.
- Value Impact: Understanding how quality installation amplifies ROI is crucial—read more in our article on Value Increase with a Roofing Company.
Warranties & Insurance Benefits
- Asphalt Shingles
- Manufacturer Warranties: 25–30 years prorated, with extended coverage available for registered roof systems.
- Insurance: Limited premium discounts; higher claim frequency can lead to increased rates over time.
- Metal Roofing
- Finish Warranties: Typically 30–40 years on paint systems like Kynar 500.
- Insurer Incentives: Many carriers offer discounts (up to 35%) for Class A fire, Class 4 hail ratings, and wind warranties—savings passed to homeowners.
Return on Investment & Resale Value
- Asphalt Shingles
- ROI: National average of 61% recouped at resale².
- Consumer Comfort: Buyers trust the familiarity of shingles, which can aid resale in conservative markets.
- Metal Roofing
- ROI: Potential for 80–95% recoupment, depending on region³.
- Market Differentiator: Durability credentials and modern aesthetics often command a premium in resale scenarios.
Personalized Decision Guide: Which Material Fits Your Home?
- Budget-Driven Projects:
- Lean toward asphalt shingles if upfront cost is the primary constraint.
- Opt for architectural or luxury lines to extend lifespan and curb appeal within your budget.
- Longevity & Low Maintenance:
- Metal roofing wins, especially if you plan to stay in your home 20+ years or want minimal upkeep.
- Energy Savings Priority:
- Evaluate local climate: metal’s reflectivity reduces cooling loads significantly; asphalt requires specialty coatings for marginal gains.
- Architectural Style & Neighborhood Fit:
- Assess HOA or historical district guidelines—some areas restrict metal profiles or colors.
- Environmental Impact:
- If reducing landfill waste and using recycled materials matters, metal emerges as the greener option.
- Insurance & Risk Mitigation:
- Check with your insurer for premium discounts on metal installations in high-risk zones.
By mapping your goals against these criteria—and consulting experienced Roofers near me—you can arrive at a confident choice.
Conclusion & Next Steps
Selecting between metal roofing and asphalt shingles is about more than material cost—it’s a strategic investment in your home’s comfort, efficiency, and resale value. Asphalt shingles deliver affordability and familiar aesthetics, while metal roofing offers unparalleled durability, sustainability, and long-term savings.
If you’re ready to upgrade with confidence, consult Elite Contracting for tailored recommendations, expert installation, and peace of mind. Whatever your decision, aligning your priorities with local roofing expertise ensures your next roof stands the test of time.